iPhone beautification

I currently own this little gem ...
Unfortuately, it looks like it has barely survived WWII. A little beaten and battered and doesn't exactly close anymore. It had a good run (just shy of a year). Provided great protection for my phone and stored all my normal wallet goods. Great gift idea.
However, it's time for a new phone cover.
I came across these cuties on Etsy.

I'm leaning towards this one...

Thoughts?